frank lloyd wright fallingwaterdivinity 2 respec talents

Direct link to Cherry Belle Callelero's post Can you explain more abou, Posted 5 years ago. What has Cai Guo-Qiang just sailed into Shanghai? The perfection of these details perfected the house itself, and even though the house tends to have structural problems that need constant maintenance due to its location, there is no question that Fallingwater, now aNational Historic Landmark,is a work of genius. The home was built for the Kaufman family, which used it as their weekend home from 1937 until 1963. http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fallingwaterfloorplan.jpg, http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fallingwater_-_DSC05600.JPG, http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Frank_Lloyd_Wright_-_Fallingwater_interior_2.JPG, http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fallingwater_detail_-_DSC05656.JPG, http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fallingwater_-_DSC05639.JPG, Frank Lloyd Wright on The Metropolitan Museum of Arts Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, https://smarthistory.org/frank-lloyd-wright-fallingwater/, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/User:Daderot, http://content.time.com/time/covers/0,16641,19380117,00.html. Frank Lloyd Wright's Fallingwater Damaged from Flooding More. Fallingwater does that the way Chartres Cathedral does that. JR and Massimo Bottura's Olympic lunch in Rio, Watch Diller Scofidio + Renfros Shed come to life. . Is Maurizio Cattelan bringing a donkey to Frieze NY? But once the Great Depression struck, the employees could no longer afford to travel there, so Kaufmann decided to convert it into a country getaway. Dec 22, 2017 - Fallingwater is the name of this AMAZING house that is built over a waterfall in the wooded hills of PA. Frank Lloyd Wright, America's most famous architect, designed the house for the Kaufmann family in 1939. You may have heard of Fallingwater in Pennsylvania. He had already written his autobiography. Proof that, for all the CAD renderings and drawing-table time a building gets, you really cant beat the creative powers of a single genius, when it comes to producing a truly singular building. Livestream of Fallingwaters classic view. How Warhol turned Marilyn Monroe into a star, Apple CEO - 'Yes JR, Art CAN change the world! To log in and use all the features of Khan Academy, please enable JavaScript in your browser. How Marc Chagall painted his own birthday - inspired by the love and gifts of his muse Bella, Jacob Kassays comeback as an architect, Berlin looks back at queer art and culture, JR helps Baltimore students say #BlackLivesMatter, MAD build hilltop village in Beverly Hills, Anish Kapoor - attack on Dirty Corner a tragedy, The antique art technique finding new favour, 'Whats that thing doing, blocking the view? Have the Rotterdam Kunsthal paintings been burned? Why are these nudes in the Barcelona Pavilion? Great Architecture of the World. Direct link to Melanie Preston's post I have been studying mate, Posted 9 years ago. Pantone Colour of the Year 2021? Maintaining Fallingwater for a global audience is an effort that involves a team of conservators, museum professionals and preservation specialists. As a member, you'll join us in our effort to support the arts. The house was commissioned by Pittsburgh department-store magnate Edgar J. Kaufmann and his wife, Liliane, as a weekend retreat located in Mill Run, Pennsylvania. The terraces form a complex, overriding horizontal force with their protrusions that liberated space with their risen planes parallel to the ground. The windows on the facade have also have a special condition where they open up at the corners, breaking the box of the house and opening it to the vast outdoors. Wright described this 1930s home as one of the great blessings to be experienced here on earth. Inspired by the architect's desire to integrate human-made structures into the natural world, Fallingwater typifies organic architecture. Wright's admiration for Japanese architecturewas importantinhisinspiration for this house, along with most of his work. Then, he did absolutely nothing for nearly a yearuntil Kaufmann traveled to Milwaukee and called up Wright, announcing hed be paying a surprise visit to his Wisconsin studio, Taliesin, to view the plans. The great American architect had last completed a building in 1929, a commission from his cousin. 1934-1935 Built in 1936-1937 Location Pennsylvania, United States Introduction This building, constructed over three levels, sits on a rock over a natural waterfall. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Wright was 67 at the time of the meeting, with few commissions in the midst of the Great Depression. Frank Lloyd Wright: Fallingwater Fallingwater, weekend residence near Mill Run, southwestern Pennsylvania, that was designed by American architect Frank Lloyd Wright for the Kaufmann family in 1935 and completed in 1937. Wright coined the term organic architecture in the early 20th century. All Rights Reserved. Facts About Fallingwater That The Public Doesn't Know But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. It opened its door as a museum in 1964 and has since hosted more than five million visitors. } Near the end of his life, Wright designed a handful of other renowned works, including the Monona Terrace Civic Center in Madison, Wisconsin and the Guggenheim Museum in New York City. More. Seriously, is this how the Contra chefs got a Michelin star? Can you make out Basquiats name in this abstract art show? The houses daring construction over a waterfall was instrumental in reviving Wrights architecture career and became one of the most famous 20th-century buildings. London: Phaidon/Chronicle Books, October 1994. if ((document.getElementById('cons_first_name').value == "" || document.getElementById('cons_first_name').value == "First Name") && (document.getElementById('cons_last_name').value == "" || document.getElementById('cons_last_name').value == "Last Name")) { This concrete concoction, in turn, is made up ofcement, sand, and rounded river gravel. The ceilings of the rooms are low, reaching only up to 6'4" in some places, in order to direct the eye horizontally to look outside. Fallingwater helped Frank Lloyd Wright make a career comeback Frank Lloyd Wright - Wikipedia Frank Lloyd Wright was considered as one of the greatest architects of all time during the 1867 to 1959 due to his creative architectural style. World Heritage Site - Fallingwater - Frank Lloyd Wright Set among trees, rocks and a waterfall,. He also brings notice to this concept by dramatically extending the chimney upwards to make it the highest point on the exterior of the house. Zaha Hadid jewellery at Art Basel Miami Beach, Okwui Enwezor to head up Venice Biennale 2015, Nike goes high-tech for Brazil's 2014 kit, Green, extreme-sports park drafted for Las Vegas, New York's High Line enters third and final phase, Eliasson and Obrist: now available as cheese, Charlotte Colbert's surreal housewife shots, The ties that bound Carlo Scarpa and Paul Klee, Take a look at Sir Paul Smith's photographs, BIG magics a ski slope from a working power plant, The World We Made is released as an iBook. That is how the connection was set up. What is JR creating for the Rio Olympics? says Christoph Terhechte, Shifting focus - the Decade interview: Josh Olins, Shifting focus - the Decade interview: The Bouroullec Brothers, Turkey or Chicken and Bell Pepper Empanada. Their solution was in the materials. Fallingwater floorplan (diagram: Arsenalbubs:CC0 1.0). In order to support them, Wright worked with engineers Mendel Glickman and William Wesley Peters. Located close to Mill Run, in southwestern Pennsylvania, and sitting halfway atop a waterfall, is Fallingwater, a unique and magical home built by the late architect Frank Lloyd Wright. More, Requests for in-kind contributions can be made here. How a young David Hockney sneaked this guy into Britain, Diller Scofidio + Renfro make a roof from jeans, Investigating the deathly side of Guy Bourdin. Knowing that Wright shared their love of nature, they commissioned him to build a summer home for the familys weekend retreat in Bear Run, PA. Wright recognized that his clients wanted something that would celebrate the landscape of their favorite country hideaway in an innovative way. Print. What will art look like in the age of AI? In 1935, Wright was commissioned by theKaufmanns, a prominent Pennsylvanian family, to replace their deteriorating summer home. The school that linked the Bauhaus to the iPhone, An art lesson from 'new' painter Etel Adnan (91). How Annie Leibovitz showed her mother's honesty, How Annie Leibovitz learned to dance with Mikhail Baryshnikov, How Annie Leibovitz let Patti Smith become herself, How Annie Leibovitz got Keith Haring to go black and white, Now you can cook like Massimo Bottura (kind of), Francis Als, his fiery football and other artworks, Edmund de Waal brings the migr experience to LA. Whats the best way to organise my kitchen? Frank Lloyd Wright's Fallingwater - Smarthistory - art history Perhaps after the pandemic, you will have the opportunity to visit Fallingwater, and if you want, you could count them. This site uses cookies to provide necessary site functionality and improve your experience. The Conservancy is a nonprofit, tax-exempt charitable organization under } Only two colors of paint were applied to the concrete, sandstone, glass, and steel structurelight ochre for the concrete, and Cherokee red for the steel. Steve McCurry at Angkor Wat on World Heritage Day, 5 Artworks you possibly didn't realise were religious, How to love, lunch and dream at the Venice Biennale, Edmund de Waal channels Giorgio Morandi in Stockholm. Heres Annie Leibovitz at Work, in Paris! Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater, detail with tree (Edgar J.Kaufmann House), 1937 (photo: Although he denied it, Wrightwas influenced by every conceivable architectural style, but Fallingwater owes little to his previous designs (the only exceptions being perhapsthe use of irregular stones that are also found on Taliesin and his interest in strong horizontal lines). Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater, steps to stream (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), Bear Run, Pennsylvania (photo: Perhaps the most famous tale to come out of the lore of Fallingwater is the improbable story that Wright, after receiving the commission procrastinated for nine months until he was forced to draw up the complete plans while his patron was drivingthe 140 miles from Milwaukee to Taliesin. After this late-career triumph, the sixty-seven year old would go on to create a series of highly original designs that would validate his claim as "The world's greatest architect." Following this revolutionary design concept, he created the masterpiece called Fallingwater. Will Renzo Piano get another Shard off the ground? Wright designed Fallingwater to rise above the waterfall over which it is built. Phaidons Frieze NY interviews Aki Sasamoto, The Store Detective: Carturesti Carusel, Bucharest, Spend a day in London with Wallpaper* City Guides, Anish Kapoor 'I want to write a grand opera', Anish Kapoor An artists job is to say Im lost. And the award for best book in the Oscars green room goes to Charles-douard Jeanneret! With its stacked silhouette, stone exterior, and neutral color scheme, it both recedes into its wooded surroundings and accentuates its waterfall. How to stare at the sun from The High Line safely! Shoshanna's off to Japan and she's got a great guide! In 1938, Wright designed additional guest quarters set into the hillside directly above the main house and linked by a covered walkway. Mill Run, PA 15464 Phone: 724-329-8501 Fax: 724-329-0655 Explore Nearby Details Amenities Meeting Space Reviews Blogs PGH Commitment Adult Admission: $30 Child Admission: $18 (6-12) Senior Admission: $30 Group Size: 20 min/no max Nobody quite knows how the Kaufmann family and Wright first became acquainted. It quickly gained fame when Time magazine featured Wright and a drawing of the building on the cover of its January 17, 1938, issue. Kaufmann and his wife expected a weekend house that would offer views of a favourite waterfall, but they were startled to find that Wrights plans situated the house directly above the waterfall. Mendel Glickman and William Wesley Peters, Robert P. Ruschak - Western Pennsylvania Conservancy. More, Enjoy Fallingwater from home with educational activities, webinars, videos, recipes and other digital content for Fallingwater enthusiasts of all ages. To avoid a complete collapse, an ingenious system was devised using tensioned cables to correct the problem and stabilize Wrights masterwork. However, we do know that Kaufmanns son, Edgar Kaufmann Jr., admired the architect's work, and studied under Wright as an apprentice at his Taliesin Studio in Wisconsin. The first step towards grow-your-own furniture? Why did Warhol, Mapplethorpe, Hockney and Ruscha all create portraits of this LA writer? After this late-career triumph, the sixty-seven year old would go on to create a series of highly original designs that would validate his claim as The worlds greatest architect.. Phaidon photographer Luc Delahaye wins the Prix Pictet 2012, Ten questions for auctioneer Simon de Pury, Georgia's billionaire leader plans a Guggenheim, Spartacus Chetwynd Turner Prize video exclusive, Dorothea Lange's Migrant Mother at Bonhams, Peter Zumthor to be given a gold medal by the queen, Francis Bacon's 'screaming pope' comes to auction, Brighton Photo Biennial hosts Magnum workshop, Melbourne University commissions Moshe Safdie, Man Ray's Portraits: first major retrospective, The Louvre's Islamic Art wing opens this weekend, Cindy Hinant's make-up, glamour and TV show, Paul Smith, Conran and Hadid's design capsule, Renzo Piano's new art museum opens this month, Cai Guo-Qiang wins Japan's Praemium Imperiale, Larry Gagosian is officially bigger than the Tate, Bouroullec brothers prints on show and for sale, Andy Warhol's Brando expected to reach $20 million, Mies van der Rohe house opens to the public, Jordan Eagles - the man who paints with blood, Richard Meier - first ever building in China, documenta 13 art bought by German Government, Marc Quinn sculpture is centre stage at Paralympics, Painted pigeons ruffle feathers at Venice Biennale, Toyo Ito and Alvaro Siza win big at Venice Biennale, Guido van der Werve runs for Rachmaninoff, Virginia Overton "parks truck" on the High Line, Richard Meier condo is most expensive ever in Israel, The architect's photographer of choice, Hlne Binet, The changing face of media and conflict reporting, Disabled and deaf artists show at Paralympic Games, Erwin Blumenfeld restored, Gianluca Gamberini in Rome, HSBC's photo prize, Stuart Ringholt naked, Rio de Janeiro Wallpaper* City Guide - free download, Nicole Kidman's Richard Meier designed apartment, Yayoi Kusama covers NY building with Yellow Trees, Christo in trouble over plans to wrap Arkansas river, Chris Burden installs skyscraper in shopping mall, Roger Ballen behind the scenes with Die Antwoord, Richard Hamilton MoCA retrospective cancelled, Marina Abramovic on her Meltdown performance, Eddie Peake talks about Tate Tanks performance, Roger Ballen - 'I fear not living anymore', Peter Zumthor working on film with Wim Wenders, Tate chooses Jeff Wall piece as Work of the Week, Nedko Solakov offers gallery goers five kilos of meat, Architects and artists experiment with space, Peter Zumthor - exclusive look at architecture models, Mona wins two Institute of Architecture awards, Take a look inside this Richard Meier house, Marina Abramovi - a very revealing interview, Rachel Whiteread unveils Whitechapel frieze, Frank Lloyd Wrights disabled-access house, Nan Goldin is awarded the MacDowell Medal, Jeff Wall photograph sets new world record, Legendary auctioneer bows out after biggest sale ever, Design Museum's holographic Louboutin homage, Stephen Shore The five things that changed my life, Haw-lin's online gallery makes first step into offline, The Phaidon guide to art speak - Performance Art. I've added too much salt. Local craftsmen quarried native sandstone and other materials from the property and completed the construction of the main house, guest house and service wing in 1939. All you have to do is listen. Historic American Buildings Survey Cervin Robinson, Photographer, 18 August 1963 EXTERIOR FROM SOUTHWEST - Frederick C. Robie House, 5757 Woodlawn Avenue, Chicago, Cook County, IL 5 x 7 inches (Library of Congress HABS ILL,16-CHIG,33--3), Frank Lloyd Wright, Frederick C. Robie House, Historic American Buildings Survey, Cervin Robinson, Photographer, 18 August 1963, exterior from southwest, 5757 Woodlawn Avenue, Chicago, Cook County, IL 5 x 7 inches (Library of Congress HABS ILL,16-CHIG,33--3). A Phaidon guide to the Fourth Plinth winner, 8,000 early Annie Leibovitz shots to go on show, JR dons toy astronaut helmet to battle storm Stella, How to get ahead in the art world by Magnus Resch, Grace tells the story behind these paper dresses, The National Trust recreates a 1930s Gay Club. Were also on Pinterest, Tumblr, and Flipboard. Have you seen Maurizio Cattelan's dinner service? Wright was not happy with his clients lack of faith, but permitted an increase in the number and diameter of the structure's steel reinforcementsKaufmann agreed to proceed. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. The cantilevered floors began to sag due to some engineering problems and there was real concern that the cantilevers would fail. Fallingwater accordingly grows from the sites rocky landscape. Apprentice Edgar Taffel recalled that after talking with Kaufmann on the phone, Wright briskly emerged from his officesat down at the table set with the plot plan and started to drawThe design just poured out of him. About Frank Lloyd Wright. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). ft. of overhanging terraces fit into the landscape as well as Wrights earlier houses had, while the 2885sq. JR's incredible new Olympics art revealed! According to legend, Wright sketched Fallingwater in only two hours. Fallingwater House - Data, Photos & Plans - WikiArquitectura The 5300-square foot homes walls and floors are constructed of local sandstone; a rock outcropping is incorporated into the living room's hearth; each bedroom has its own terrace; and its cornerless windows open outward so windowpanes wont interrupt visitors' view. Celebrating creativity and promoting a positive culture by spotlighting the best sides of humanityfrom the lighthearted and fun to the thought-provoking and enlightening. But last summer, a UNESCO committee decided they needed to review additional information before making a final decision. please answer anyone, if you know ! These thoughtful aesthetic decisions essentially camouflage the dwelling. than expected. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. Like living in it and all of that? However, the family assumed personal ownership in 1933, and decided to update the plots dilapidated buildings. Fallingwater has received plenty of accolades and honors over the years. Frank Lloyd Wright's Fallingwater Hours: Visit website for hours of operation Route 381 South, 1491 Mill Run Rd. Meet the same-sex couple who got married 14 times, Joe Bradleys not too-mature mid-career show, Marina Abramovi in the library, with the ancient manuscripts, Looks like JR just made it into the dictionary, JR does the cover of the new Arcade Fire album, A Marilyn Monroe postcard from Ellsworth Kelly, Annie Leibovitz shoots Star Wars for Vanity Fair, A Phaidon guide to Mario Testinos art collection, Photos That Changed The World - Migrant Mother, Grace Coddingtons part in Edward Enninfuls rise, Why John Pawson is the ideal Noguchi Award winner, JR and Agns Vardas small-town film comes to Cannes, How drinks with Erik Satie helped Man Ray make this 'gift', Grace Coddington styles Elle Fanning for Vogue cover, How Sottsass and Scarpa pushed back against modernism, A Phaidon guide to Brad Pitts favourite sculptor, When Keith Haring turned a men's room into art, Magnus and Massimo take a trip to La La Land, Pentagram put The Handmaid's Tale on The High Line. I wonder how many architects of any period in time could design a Fallingwater in two hours as a passenger in a car or as documented in other reports in about two hours time. Fallingwater is located in the mountains of Southwestern Pennsylvania, also known as the Laurel Highlands, in Mill Run, Fayette County, which is about 70 miles southeast of Pittsburgh. Cross Country by EV to Frank Lloyd Wright World Heritage Sites to Raise And in 2019, UNESCO added Fallingwater (and seven other Frank Lloyd Wright-designed sites) to its list of World Heritage Sites, marking an impressive international recognition of Fallingwater's legacy in the world of architecture. Commissioned by wealthy department store owner Edgar J. Kaufmann and completed in 1937, the homes cantilevered tiers hang suspended atop a 30-foot waterfallWrights ingenious way of melding the man-made structure with its natural surroundings [PDF]. Corrections? His career was seemingly near retirementthe early success of his Prairie style residences in the first decade of the 1900s had abated following the negative publicity of his personal life. These cookies do not store any personal information. Fallingwater - You're in the Wright Place | Frank Lloyd Wright Sites Fallingwater House - Discover Frank Lloyd Wright's - Your Art Blog function alertEmpties() { Yet, while the building marks a change in the architects practice most notably in his pioneering use of concrete, which, at the time, was seen as dangerously modern by the consultant engineers the house deserves its place within architectural history, not just because of its historical importance, but because of its undoubted perfection. What links Mies vander Rohe to Ferris Bueller? Kerry James Marshall's 30-foot tribute to black lawyers, A glimpse at David Wojnarowiczs Sex Series, Jennifer Lawrence checks out the new JR show, Alicia Keys plays for JR and Massimo in New York, The Jackson portrait Warhol worried TIME would junk, The painting that pushed Luc Tuymans to 'authentic forgery', Olafur Eliasson creates a brick tower for the Lego family. Can you say Wright challenged his apprentices when your building iscomplete, that the landscape is more beautiful than it was before?3, this delicate synthesis of nature and the built environment probably counts as the main reason why Fallingwater is such a well-loved work. Fallingwater - Wikipedia Mid-Century Modern Homes That Shaped the Future of Architecture Design, Frank Lloyd Wright Exhibition at MoMA Celebrates the Architects 150th Birthday, Beach House Designed by Frank Lloyd Wright Is Available on Airbnb for $150 A Night, Gingerbread Replica of Frank Lloyd Wrights Fallingwater. Fallingwater, a National Historic Landmark . However, Kaufmann was won over by Wrights argument that the house would allow the waterfall to become an integral part of their lives, and could constantly hear the falling water while inside the dwelling. High Line architects create volcano-style resort, Why Danh Vo is still possessed by The Exorcist. Reprint edition: Da Capo Press, April 1991 . Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), Mill Run, Pennsylvania, 1935, Color pencil on tracing paper, 15-3/8 x 27-1/4 inches, , The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, Frank Lloyd Wright, Fallingwater (Edgar J. Kaufmann House), Mill Run, Pennsylvania, 1935, Color pencil on tracing paper, 15-3/8 x 27-1/4 inches, The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, Edgar Kaufmann Jr. pointedout that Wrights famous concept of Organic Architecture stems from his Transcendentalist background. The exterior of Fallingwater enforces a strong horizontal pattern with the bricks and long terraces. Some of his most high-profile commissions came after, including the Guggenheim Museum in New York City. Piano, Kusama and Kahn up for Design of The Year, Bouroullec Brothers design Ready Made Curtain, Scorsese exhibition goes back to the director's roots, The Summer Is Over for Luc Tuymans at Zwirner NY, Korea's Hae-gue Yang debuts at Haus der Kunst, John Pawson designs new Schrager Miami venture, David Bowie first new single and video in 10 years, Le Corbusier, painter, photographer and polymath, gets full NYC retrospective at MoMA next summer, Martino Gamper makes a meal out of Moroso, The Design Museum's extraordinary stories, Owen Hatherley blasts architectural photography, Anish Kapoor's first ever show in Australia, Daniel Baer on Richard Avedon's Observations, Ten questions for graphic artist Jamie Hewlett, 'Lost' TV series inspires new LA art show, Yale Art Gallery expansion opens tomorrow, Keith Coventry talks about Junk Paintings at Pace, Shore and Parr among top bankable photographers, Buildings that changed the world - Brasilia, Brazil, What to expect from Kraftwerk at The Tate, Ten questions for photographer Hlne Binet, Oscar Niemeyer, Brazil's Picasso of Concrete, Cinema's snappers reassembled Marclay-style, It's official: video games are art (well, sort of), Susan Meiselas sends a postcard from America, Stephen Shore talks Warhol, colour and creativity, Studio Orta replaces St Pancras Olympic rings, John Pawson curates Phaidon online exhibition. Think of a diving board. Another thought was the following statement by Wright: Can you say Wright challenged his apprentices when your building is complete, that the landscape is more beautiful than it was before? - He was a true organic architect. Paul Smith threw a party for Martin Parr this week! As a building, Fallingwater looks very different from Wrights earlier work. How many paintings can you name in this video? The house was built as a weekend home for owners Mr. Edgar Kaufmann, his wife, and their son, whom he developed a friendship with through their son who was studying at Wright's school, the Taliesin Fellowship. Fallingwater is Frank Lloyd Wright's organic architecture-style design atop a waterfall in Pennsylvania. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Wright had only built a few buildings in the previous decade, the Great Depression had diminished demand for new projects, and, adding insult to injury, his younger peers considered his style to be anachronistic. On July 10, 2019, UNESCO inscribed Fallingwater and seven other Frank Lloyd Wright-designed buildings to the World Heritage List. Frank Lloyd Wright's Fallingwater - Visit Pittsburgh Years after his parents deaths in the 1950s, Edgar Kaufmann, acting on his fathers wishes, entrusted the building and nearby land to the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy in 1963.

When Was Ezekiel Born, Child Nutrition Conference 2023, Survivor 44 Premiere Date, Osfa Letter Code Column, Parchment How Long Does It Take, Clos Pegase Hommage Chardonnay, Bhartiya City Mall Bangalore, What Happened At Kent State That Was So Shocking?,